Unthinking respect for authority is the greatest enemy of truth

Welcome to Infoshop News
Tuesday, February 09 2010 @ 06:56 PM UTC

Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer

The StatePittsburgh: On Tuesday a friend of mine was sentenced to an egregious 2 1/2 to 5 years in the state penitentiary for writing graffiti. That's not a typo. Danny has already been incarcerated since January awaiting sentencing. At the time of his trial, he faced a possible 221 years in prison.

Sentences of this magnitude are unheard of in graffiti cases. Of course, this is just political maneuvering for Pittsburgh's local government. Liberal-ass faux-hipster city councilman William Peduto pressured the judicial system to prosecute Danny to the most outlandish extent of the law.

Much of the $713,801 dollars in damage Danny has been charged with is in the East End of Pittsburgh, an area currently undergoing a process of gentrification. Business owners and politicians have voiced grievances about the adverse effect of graffiti on their ability to attract revenue to the area.

"The passion for destruction is also a creative passion".

To many practitioners, graffiti is a visceral rebellion, a response to the alienation of the commodity economy carrying with it a desperate sense of immediacy. It is a very literal assertion of the value of creativity over the sanctity of property, a visual declaration of the will to live.

When abundant, its presence has been attributed to the decline of property values, which translates to lower rent for landlords, less property tax revenue for the state, and often a reduction in profit for businesses affected. In short, a general diminishing of revenue for the economy, a falling rate of profit not inaugurated by impersonal contradictions of capitalism, but by the creative actions of individuals.

Of course, in many instances, the image of graffiti has been commodified, exchanged as sustenance for the economy. This should come as no surprise. The recuperation of images threatening to the economy is capitalism's (relatively) new way of waging war against those who fight to supersede its values. This process is as applicable to graffiti as it is to the sale of anarchist literature, or the money generated from news stories about militant demonstrations.

This is no reason to despair. The image of a rebellious act being sold for profit does not necessarily negate its radical potential, despite the hysterical assertions of countless French theorists and anarcho-punks. The process of commodification is a constant conflict between combatants and capitalists. Hence, it is an issue of the degree of recuperation and how hard we fight against it. Hippie culture, which might have been threatening 40 years ago, has been so thoroughly appropriated by the economy (while fighting back so pathetically) that it can be argued that it no longer challenges the established social order. Mark Ecko's "Getting Up", however won't stop the majority of capitalists from harboring a more visceral fear of graffiti than of most anarchist demonstrations when it comes to the effect on their profits.

So what can be done about Danny's predicament? I don't have all the answers, and I'm hoping for suggestions. Autonomous actions are key at this point. I'm sure that many people would be motivated just by seeing demands for freedom next to his alleged nom de guerre "MFONE" (think "motherfucker one, not m-phone) adorning walls across America. Of course, that's not enough.

We're going to try to raise money for an appeal of his sentence, but i'm not sure how viable a possibility a reduced sentence is at this point.

To be perfectly honest I feel that I could have done a lot more before this trial. Maybe I fucked up. I could have organized a benefit block party for him, or a show, or something of that nature. But it seems like everyone in Pittsburgh has a case now, so people were justifiably busy organizing benefits for anti-fascist defendants, amongst other things.

Anyone with prisoner support experience is more than welcome to offer some suggestions.

Unfortunately, it wouldn't surprise me if anarchists didn't understand why it's so necessary to support Danny. These situations are an important opportunity for anarchists to show that we support those rebels who may not be fully conscious of the radical possibilities of their actions, but have a hatred of the values of this economy.

Substantial prisoner support around these types of situations could show local people that we will palpably support their struggles, even when the entirety of the media, the police force, and neighborhood watch groups have vilified them.

"A revolt against the spectacle — even if limited to a single district... calls everything into question because it is a human protest against a dehumanized life, a protest of real individuals against their separation from a community that would fulfill their true human and social nature and transcend the spectacle."

-The Decline and Fall of the Spectacle-Commodity Economy


http://www.kdkaradio.com/pages/2660164.php?contentType=4&contentId=2474951

Trackback

Trackback URL for this entry: http://news.infoshop.org/trackback.php?id=20080726202053561

Here's what others have to say about 'Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer':

Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer « From Behind Bars
Tracked on Sunday, July 27 2008 @ 01:02 PM UTC

Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer | 16 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer
Authored by: HPWombat on Sunday, July 27 2008 @ 09:31 AM UTC
Good article. I've had thoughts about prisoner support that are mirrored here. I am not in prisoner support circles, so I couldn't say how this operates.

"Graffitism", which may be unique to Columbus, is a higher crime than normal vandalism and most people that are punished are given the option to help "Graffiti Busters" (Part of "Keep America Beautiful"...you know, the Indian crying over litter?) which will reduce their sentence. I think in Chicago and New York there are large anti-graffiti groups and I'm curious at how it is received in the larger cities?

The anti-graffiti surveillance culture is sick. Regular areas for graffiti activity have cameras placed with a variety of other gadgets, includes lights and a voice that threatens criminal prosecution when activated. I've yet to see these things, but they have been in the paper a couple of times a I've heard a few stories here and there about it.

---
Towards a more critical discussion http://midwest.azone.org/forum/23
Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer
Authored by: praxisnine on Sunday, July 27 2008 @ 11:37 AM UTC
Unfortunately, this kind of sentence is not an isolated event. Stockton, California is another example. Can't remember the name of the person any more, but he got several years in prison while the DA puffed and bragged in the paper about how the city was 'safer' now that they'd sent a "message." And that would be laughable if it wasn't sick. Stockton has a phenomenally high MURDER rate that you think people would be more worried about.
Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer
Authored by: praxisnine on Sunday, July 27 2008 @ 11:51 AM UTC
http://www.recordnet.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070112/A_NEWS0803/701120327

Here's a link to an editorial about it. The case is chalked up to 'bad parenting.' But good news "ANARCHY REIGNS" according to the article.
Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer
Authored by: Cornelius on Sunday, July 27 2008 @ 03:51 PM UTC
As far a prisoner support goes, the easiest place to start is posting Danny's address so that people can send him letters of support and correspondence, assuming he wants them. Prison can be very isolating and dreary, and receiving letters and cards and literature is a good start towards helping people weather their time. It won't give him less time, but it will make his time a little bit more bearable.
Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer
Authored by: nostalgia on Sunday, July 27 2008 @ 04:12 PM UTC
I wasn't sure about posting his address because it his his address at county jail and I'm not sure when he is being transferred to the state prison (i don't want people to send letters and he not get them).

The problem about allegheny county jail (amongst others) is that you can't send books there unless they are through amazon.com or a similar company.

I'm going to call his father tomorrow and find out when he is being transferred, you can send letters (don't talk about illegal activities, please) to

Daniel Montano
DOC # 128581
Allegheny County Jail
950 Second Avenue
Pittsburgh, PA 15219

But again, I'm not sure when he's being transferred. We are going to set up a support site for him shortly.
ABC
Authored by: fred jones on Sunday, July 27 2008 @ 07:12 PM UTC
In the past, the ABC (Anarchist Black Cross) has had good info about prisoner support. In philly, they do books through bars. I'm an admirer of their hard work.

Good luck,
jones

Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer
Authored by: scooter on Sunday, July 27 2008 @ 10:14 PM UTC
Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer
Authored by: nostalgia on Monday, July 28 2008 @ 02:38 AM UTC
Thanks for the suggestions everyone. I am actually involved in a books to prisoners program in Pittsburgh, I've done prisoner solidarity work before, I was just hoping for new suggestions. Like how likely it is to get a sentence appealed when the defendant plead guilty but the sentence is obviously egregious. Or any good ideas for fundraisers. Or other campaigns. Thanks a lot for telling me about ABC Philly I will contact them.
Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer
Authored by: awed on Monday, July 28 2008 @ 06:57 AM UTC
I was struck by this sentence in the original article:

"it seems like everyone in Pittsburgh has a case now, so people were justifiably busy organizing benefits for anti-fascist defendants, amongst other things."

I know that Pittsburgh is an active city, especially with POG. Are there really that many people in Pittsburgh with cases? What are a majority of these cases for? It would be interesting if somebody there could write an article about this. I sometimes wonder what has made Pittsburgh such a focal point of activism. Is it mostly students or young people who have moved there to live or long-term older residents?

About this specific case with mfone, the sentence is entirely too extreme.
Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer
Authored by: yinzarchist on Monday, July 28 2008 @ 10:53 AM UTC
Seemed more a statement on feeling that way, not that there is a huge number persee. As has been posted elsewhere there's a couple cases pending from antifa protests in DC. Last year there were some cases from an anti-war fast. In the past couple years there's been a lot of anti-war cases around lockdowns, protests, property damage at the recruiting station (though most incidents haven't seemed to result in arrests), etc. When there are arrests though it's often people arrested with friends or people they regularly work with, so in the short term it's a huge tax on specific groups or social networks.

Pittsburgh has a lot going for it. Good number of experienced organizers. Large skill base. Good age diversity. Low number and activity of authoritarean socialists, good number of well meaning liberals that like to work with radicals, a lot of diverse groups working on different projects. A good balance between dual institutions type projects (radical bookstore, free bike program, community farm, fnb, books to prisoner stuff, etc) and individuals-groups trying to confront the state/capitalism more directly (pog, ara when it's active, individuals and more informal networks that take action, etc). It's not a clean divide though. There's crossover membership and groups themselves often do a bit of both. There's not much focus on student activism here, which I think has been a big help in being rooted in the community, though it's left the campuses too open to authoritareans. Most of the radicals I work with are either from Pittsbugh or grew up within an hours drive in more rural areas.

There's also characteristics inherent to the city itself. We've lost half our population in the last 50 years due to de-industrialation so there's only about 300,000 people left in the city proper. Compared to other cities there's a much greater percentage of anarchist or anarchist friendly folks here. Cheap housing, solid working class attitudes and remant union solidarity in lots of stable neighborhoods. Low levels of gentrification so not too much forced moving around. City government is kinda old style democratic machine politics, with a newer progressive edge. Politicians still dislike anarchists, but there's enough liberal crossover support there's a greater political price to state attacks.

Make no mistake though. We're still struggling with a lot of the issues everyone else is. Divisions, some over legitimate political differences. Some over personality conflicts or incidents. Some no one's really sure why. Some over the difficulty for all of us in dealing with anti-oppression issues, and doing some effectively. How can we work through this stuff to still be able to work together? There's a lot of blame to go around and seemingly not a lot of easy answers or listening. State socialists are on the attack. The violence vs. non-violence thing comes up over and over. Some liberals are clearly trying to marginalize radicals and destroy our links to other communities. The lack of tighter relationships within the anarchist movement is making it harder to fight back. There's never enough people or enough money. The state seems poised for a new round of intimidation. The list goes on, so does the struggle.
Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer
Authored by: nostalgia on Wednesday, May 20 2009 @ 03:59 AM UTC
Danny's still in jail. This sucks. But these burners definitely don't. Photobucket Photobucket Photobucket Photobucket Photobucket
Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer
Authored by: debation on Wednesday, May 20 2009 @ 12:55 PM UTC
damn son. i can't even wrap my mind around the metaphysical explosions rocked by the sick blasts of mfone. word is bond. that shit is so ill.
Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer
Authored by: Eyedea on Wednesday, May 20 2009 @ 09:41 PM UTC
That red, black, and white piece is killing me (although, I don't know if I would've gone with the spots. . .)! It's a shame talent like that is gonna be locked up. It should be free and prosperous!

If I lived in Pittsburgh I'd be all over that case trying to help out. But I don't. I could say something corny like, "solidarity with Danny Montano!", but that wouldn't do much good. This article upsets me though, if only because I used to have an affinity for graffiti subculture and art. If I still had the 'stuff' I would go out and do some work right now, but I had the wind took out of me. I was terrified just to be in the courtroom myself, getting 6 months probation and community service; so I can empathize with Danny.

If anything - and I believe the article said something similar to this - graffiti calls into question the relevance of commodity production and property-value over human creativity (obviously, all of the people on this thread already know the answer to that question). The desire to commit acts of anonymous creativity which takes hold of the graff writer is a powerful thing. Even if most graffiti is done for the infamy (which isn't to say the need for individual recognition is something to repudiated), the act itself, while it may appear petty, says a whole lot about the contradiction that people experience when their own desires are cast aside by the values imposed by the economy. And it exposes those values in a very bold way, I think. What other 'crime' shows the dominance of the economy over liberty? Maybe theft? It's really the only crime I can think of that, in all cases, is a situation where judicial rhetoric exclaims the precedence of commodities over humans.
Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer
Authored by: Gerald on Wednesday, May 20 2009 @ 02:07 PM UTC
"I'm sure that many people would be motivated just by seeing demands for freedom next to his alleged nom de guerre "MFONE" (think "motherfucker one, not m-phone) adorning walls across America."


I can see it now!
Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer
Authored by: communitycntrl on Wednesday, May 20 2009 @ 06:35 PM UTC
*graffiti is the single biggest art movement in the history of the human species.*

be a part of it, appreciate the special time we live in, don't let anyone diss graffiti.

also, graffiti is a form of expropriation. in a world where all space is owned, graffiti is the theft of space.
Prison Sentence for Pittsburgh Graffiti Writer
Authored by: Eyedea on Wednesday, May 20 2009 @ 10:04 PM UTC